Ask the Doctor - Answers to your Parenting Questions

Healing child after damage from harsh treatment and following Gina Ford

Hi
My name is Mariam and I am a mother of 3.  I live in South  Africa.  I am so glad I came across ur site n I am becoming a new loving parent and its beautiful!  Unfortunately for my firstborn i followed Gina Ford and my son and I were always discontented..I was so fixed on routine I would scold and be harsh with him whenever he wouldn't sleep or eat!leaving him to cry for long spells or forcing him to eat..he was barely 1yr and 4months and I was pregnant with my daughter...thus weaning him and not carrying him much..also shifted him to his own room and becoming upset when he came to me and wanting to touch me at nite..when daughter was born I was highly stressed with 2 small ones and He became the target of my frustrations..often hitting him or locking him in the bathroom..resulting in him having regular tantrums and erratic moods causing hubby and I lots of stress..He is now 5 and half and is always wanting to be first,is selfish,and hits/bites sister when she doesn't listen to him..He is lazy and doesn't like doing things for himself and finds little things to be upset about especially before school..He is very intelligent and loving and generally well behaved outside the home!
Now that I am adopting Aha! Parenting, he becomes angry and says stupid or u fat pig....whereas before he wouldn't dare say that! My hubby cant tolerate such indolence!

Plz help.

Ever Grateful
Mariam

Mariam-
I am so glad that you are finding more compassionate ways to be with your son.  The transition to compassionate parenting is tough.  Kids do begin to express their anger at us.  It's understandable that your husband is upset by your son's insolence.   Your husband is right that your son needs to know that people in your family never call each other names or raise their voices at each other.  Of course, this means that we as parents need to model loving compassion as we relate to our children. 

So what can you do to stop your son's rudeness?  Well, it's obvious that he needs to know such behavior isn't ok.  But he certainly knows that by now.  He is purposely breaking the rules to push against you, to show you how much he needs your help.  So continue to be very clear that you don't speak to him that way and you don't want him to speak to you that way.  But to actually stop the behavior, you'll need to give your son some help to heal the emotions that are driving it.

Your goal is to surface all those hurt feelings and fear that are under the anger and driving it.  Your son needs to cry and wail and writhe and show you the years of fear and hurt he is holding.  Until he does, he will be full of rage. 

However, your son does not yet feel safe enough to show you those feelings.  So you need to build a sense of safety for him first.  To do this, begin spending Special Time with him every day.  Here's a link on that:

What's So Special About Special Time?

This link also has links to other articles with lots of games to play with your child, which will increase his feelings of safety. 

After you have begun building safety with Special Time, when your son is insolent, take a deep breath, and turn it into a game. Say, very playfully,  "Wait a minute?  Are you being rude to me?  Your own mama who loves you so much?  We'll see about that!  You can't call your mother a noxious nincompoop! You come here, you rude boy, you!"  (I know he is calling you much worse, but you are ignoring what he said and turning it into a joke.  He is only using those words to provoke you, because he so desperately needs your help.) 

Then you chase him and grab him up and toss him around, maybe throw him over your back and carry him around if you can, or wrestle on the couch, chanting "I'm NOT a noxious nincompoop!  We'll see about that!  No more rudeness!"   He will most likely come up with more names.  Ignore the ones that feel too mean, but make up more that are as silly as possible.  (This may be hard on the spot, so get ready now:  Dastardly DumbDumb? Jiggly Jabberwocky?) Get him giggling a lot. 

You are showing him that his aggression is allowed and you are not taking offense.  Essentially, you are transforming his rudeness into something harmless and using it as a signal that at this moment he needs to reconnect with you to melt those mean feelings around his heart.  At some point in all this, either he will relax into a nice connection, in which case you go on with your day, feeling closer.  OR he will get hysterical, and you will help him cry out those feelings.  Summon up all your compassion and say, "Sweetheart, I hear how angry you are at me.  I'm not playing now.  I won't let you speak to me that way." 

 A version of this is described here:

When Your Child Is Angry But Can't Cry: Building Safety Through Play

So don't worry -- your son's rudeness is temporary.  Your son has already begun the process of healing -- he is beginning to show you his feelings.  As you rebuild your relationship with him, you will see big changes in his behavior. 

Good luck!
Dr. Laura

View Older Comments

Mariam commented on 09-Dec-2011 05:25 PM
Dear Dr. Laura, Thank you for your guidance! I try to stick to aha principles as much as possible.. ...My son now openly and frequently mentions that he is 'scared' of me!How do I respond to him? How do I alleviate his fear? Many Thanks Mariam
Laura Markham commented on 09-Dec-2011 05:26 PM
Dear Mariam, You can build a sense of safety between you by playing with your son. Next time he mentions that he's scared of you, take a deep breath and find a way to get him giggling about it. You can do this either by: 1.Pretending that YOU are scared
of HIM (exaggerate how frightened you are by jumping in fear, hiding behind a chair, etc) until he starts giggling and acting like his is the scary one... or 2. Winking at him so he knows you're joking and then saying "Everybody should be scared of me, I'm
a big scary monster" and start to act scary but then trip and fall. Act just scary enough to get him giggling but not scary enough to really scare him, and puncture your scariness by being silly and goofy and ineffectual. You'll know you're on the right track
if he's giggling and wants you to keep doing it. Good luck! Dr. Laura

Hide Older Comments

Search Q&A's