“Our 26 month old is overall really excellent with the three month old. But now the baby is starting to play with toys, and the toddler always grabs them away from him. The baby is still too small to care that the toy gets taken...for now. Until now, we've handled sharing toys as you suggest--we don't force it, we talk about taking turns, asking the other child if they're done, etc. I'm a little less sure how to apply this logic when there is an age discrepancy. We can't ask the baby if he's done. I feel quite certain that I don't want to force my toddler to share, but sometimes I find myself saying, "Your brother is using that!" because it seems like he shouldn't just be able to take every toy the baby plays with.“
There's a reason "taking candy from a baby" has come to symbolize an easy but immoral abuse of power. You're right to feel uncomfortable with your toddler's
compulsive grabbing from the baby; it's not good for the baby -- and it's not good for your toddler.
That's because his behavior isn't actually about the toy he's grabbing. Compulsive behavior of any kind signals a deeper unmet need or feeling we can't
verbally express. In other words, if your child "always" grabs whatever the baby is holding, then he has some big feelings that are driving him to
compulsively take from his sibling.
The most likely hypothesis is that those feelings have to do with guarding his place in the family, and with some worry about sharing his parents. I've
never heard of an older sibling who didn't find it hard to share his parents.
Is grabbing toys always about sibling rivalry? No. A 26 month old is just developing social skills, and this could even be seen as a clumsy attempt to
"relate" to his brother. So in cases where the toy grabbing is sporadic, I don't think adults need to intervene. Children aren't always unhappy about
the toy being taken from them, and they learn a lot from the interaction, whether they're the grabber or grabbee.
But in this case, the grabbing is constant, so it sounds like both kids will benefit from adult support. Whether this is sibling rivalry or simple toy
envy, it's a terrific opportunity to teach your son some social skills AND help him process his feelings, while you let your baby know you're there
if he needs you. Here's how.
1. Interpret for your children. "I see Baby shaking his rattle so hard and laughing...Big brother is curious....Big brother wants to try the rattle, too.....Big brother takes the rattle...Baby looks surprised...Now brother shakes the rattle...shake shake shake...Baby laughs and laughs....Big brother laughs too...Now Baby has the giraffe...He's trying to put it in his mouth...Now Big brother wants the giraffe....Big brother takes the giraffe....Baby looks surprised."
Why? Because your 26 month old isn't actually aware of what he's doing and what effect it has on his brother. He's just feeling an impulse and following
it. Your words help him develop self-awareness.
And while your three month old isn't quite sure yet what you're saying, he knows you're acknowledging him, which matters. He needs your help to understand
If you can do it with empathy and as little judgment as possible, it helps both children feel heard, which diffuses upset feelings. (Some version of this
works from babyhood right through the teen years.)
2. Empathize, and ask questions to build empathy. "That rattle sounds pretty great, doesn't it? You want to shake it, too....Your brother looked surprised when you took the rattle...I wonder if he was done with his turn?....What do you think he would say if we asked him?"
3. Don't force children to share. I appreciate your certainty that you don't want to force your toddler to share. Forcing sharing seems
to actually delay the development of sharing skills! Kids need to feel secure in their ownership before they can share. Instead, as you've apparently
done, I suggest families introduce the concept of taking turns. (“Baby has the rattle...Then it will be your turn.")
4. Let the child in possession of the toy decide how long his turn lasts. If kids think adults will snatch a toy away once the adult's
random idea of "long enough" has passed, you're modeling grabbing, and the child usually becomes more possessive. If, by contrast, the child is free
to use the toy for as long as he wants, he can fully enjoy it and then give it up with an open heart.
But how do you know whether the baby is done with his turn? Teach your son to ask. "You want the rattle? I wonder if your brother is done with it? Why don't you bring him a different toy, to see if he's ready to swap."
Now, most of the time, the baby will happily switch toys. He'll probably think it's a game. That's fine. Your son is still learning reciprocity, and to
respect his brother's turn. But of course as the baby gets older, this won't always work. Teaching your child to offer a swap from the time the baby
is small lays the groundwork for him to respect the baby's choice as the baby becomes assertive and clings to the toy.
5. Help your son wait for his turn. Since you're a parent, you've already noticed the hard part about letting the toy-holder decide when
his turn is up-- the other child has to wait! Naturally, kids find that excruciating.
But a rigid attachment to a specific toy isn't really about the child's need for that toy. It's about his desperate attempt to regulate all those feelings
spilling out of his emotional backpack. He thinks that if he can just have that one toy, things will be ok. (You probably know adults like that.
:-)) But of course, as soon as he gets that one thing, the baby will pick up a new toy, and the older child will desperately need to take that new
toy to feel okay.
The best way to help your child process those big feelings is with a "scheduled meltdown."
After you've spent a few days working with these ideas, including making it clear that the person who has the toy decides how long their turn will last,
you can begin intervening. When your son starts to grab from the baby, put your hand on the toy to stop him. Say "I see you want that....It's the baby's turn....Your turn will be next...Can you find another toy to play with right now?"
If he happily finds another toy, terrific! If not, he will either get angry, or begin to cry. If he gets angry, soften yourself and speak to the upset
under the anger: "I'm sorry it's so hard, Sweetie...I'll help you wait." Your compassion will help him move past the anger to
the tears underneath.
Those are feelings that need to come out. Stay close, tell him he's safe and you're right there. Your goal is to create safety with your empathy: Acknowledge
how much he wants that toy, and how hard it is to wait for his turn. Don't worry if he cries harder at that -- we all feel safer to "let it all out"
when we feel understood.
So the way to "cure" your son's compulsive grabbing is to give him a chance to actually face all those uncomfortable feelings. When we (humans) experience
our emotions without acting on them, the emotions dissipate. Little children, especially, often have emotional backpacks overflowing with upsets they
haven't felt up to facing. It's your loving, compassionate presence that makes him feel safe enough for that deep dive.
But the amazing thing is, after "showing" you those pent-up emotions, he probably won't even care about the toy he was waiting for, and you'll see his
What can you expect after this "scheduled meltdown"?
- Much less grabbing.
- A happier, more flexible, more cooperative child.
- A child who's more comfortable with his emotions, and thus more able to regulate them.
- A closer relationship with your child.
- A happier baby who is free to explore items without having them snatched away.
- Two children with growing self-awareness and social skills.
- A positive foundation for your children's relationship with each other.
You might even find yourself wanting to schedule more meltdowns!